There are many reasons why you may want to use online privacy and anonymity tools like VPNs, proxies, and Tor. From hiding your identity while p2p downloading and gaining access to another country’s Netflix, to browsing the web anonymously and staying safe on public Wi-Fi networks.
However, selecting the right solution for your needs can be confusing, especially if you aren’t much of a “techie”. Though all of these tools change your IP address and allow you to access geo-restricted content, they’re considerably different with the way they function and get things done.
As such, you may be looking for a detailed comparison of Tor vs VPN vs Proxy to learn more about each of these tools and find the right one for you. Well, consider your search over because in this guide, you will learn all there is about Proxy vs VPN vs Tor along with their respective pros and cons.
What is a VPN?
Unlike all the other anonymity tools that have been discussed above, a Virtual Private Network (VPN) provides the highest security level as well as best online privacy (anonymity). When you connect to a VPN, you are first able to mask your real IP and location and show the public server that you are sending the request from a different destination.
How Does a VPN Work?
VPN services have multiple servers throughout the globe. For instance, PureVPN has a pool of around 750+ servers spread across 6 continents. When you connect to a VPN, you will be asked to choose a location. When you connect to the Internet through the VPN, the public server would see the location that you have choose via the VPN, and not yours. As a result, you will be able to hide your real IP.
Apart from masking your real IP, a VPN provides an encrypted tunnel that allows you to keep your data hidden from unwanted eyes. With the data safely encrypted, no one will be able to see your sensitive information online.
Pros and Cons of a VPN
Pros of VPN
- When compared to a proxy and even Tor, VPNs are much faster. There is very little slow down to the raw connection speed when connected to VPN servers, thus making it much more reliable.
- Users will be able to spoof their location with the click of a button.
- Serves as an excellent solution for those who wish to stream geo-restricted content.
- Just as effective at P2P file sharing.
- Some VPNs are known for keeping no logs, thus ensuring complete privacy
Cons of VPN
- Free VPNs not always come with all the premium features enabled.
- Free VPNs are not trustworthy.
- You need a paid VPN service for anonymous browsing and security.
What is a Proxy?
Proxy usually means substitute. So as the meaning suggests, Internet proxy servers allow users to direct their traffic through the assistance of a substitute server. Out of private and public proxies, private ones tend to be more stable and secure.
There are a number of reasons why you would want to do that.
For instance, you want to visit a website which is not accessible in your country or region. To get past such country or ISP imposed restriction, you may want to try proxy. In short, a proxy server would allow you to enjoy anonymity from people spying in on your network to see your activities.
Nevertheless, you can find both free and paid proxy servers on the Internet. However, you can never be sure if the free version can be trusted or not.
How Does a Proxy Work?
Image Credit: Gohacking.com
Your ISP is usually the service that lets you connect to the Internet, and without any anonymity tool, the Internet server knows your real IP. However, when you use a proxy service, your requests are first sent to a proxy server that forwards the request on your behalf, ultimately keeping your real IP hidden. You can see the working of a proxy in the above example.
Pros and Cons of a Proxy
- Proxies serve as web filters. Settings are applied directly to web browsers, regardless of which one is being used i.e. Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer, Safari
- Depending on the type of server you are connected to, you can benefit from all of its features too. This can include location, speed and security as well.
- Proxies only secure any and all traffic passing through the web browser, and only as long as appropriate settings have been set in place.
- Proxy protocols are limited to HTTP, HTTPS and SOCKS. HTTP and SOCKS offers no encryption, while HTTPS does, even though it is the same as what is available on SSL websites.
- Since proxies are specifically designed to cater to browsers, they do not protect all of your internet traffic.
- Proxies are more or less unreliable, and can be a nuisance for those who are particularly concerned about their online security as they tend to pass the user’s original IP address to destination sites.
- Proxies need to be configured manually for different applications. What is even more troublesome is the fact that not all applications support proxies in the first place.
- Some free proxies are known to infect a user’s device, effectively turning it into a bot.
What is Tor?
Initially released in 2002, Tor offers you a free browser that you can use to conduct anonymous surfing on the Internet. The name was originally derived from the project, The Onion Router. It is the first line of action for most users on the web when it comes to online anonymity.
How Does Tor Work?
Image Credit: Fossbytes.com
When you use a Tor browser and open a website, your request goes through a network of several relays (computers on the network). While passing through different relays, your traffic is encrypted and re-encrypted continuously until your request is sent to the public Internet where it is decrypted. As a result, your real IP is kept hidden throughout the time you surf the Internet.
Pros and Cons of Tor
- Users become untraceable
- Impossible to attack or shut down since it is a distributed network, after all.
- As mentioned earlier, it is completely free of cost.
- Taking into account how internet traffic is forwarded through different nodes, using Tor can be frustrating due to its speed.
- An unsuitable tool for P2P file sharing, largely because it is slow and affects the network as a whole thus affecting other users on the network.
- Ineffective at location spoofing, once again because of slow connection speeds.
- A relay or node might be operated by a hacker or government agency, thus failing its purpose.
Things to Consider When Choosing VPN vs Proxy vs Tor
Now that we are done with the VPN vs. Proxy vs. Tor, let’s take a quick look at some factors that you must assess when choosing the best service:
- Level of Encryption: Make sure that the service you opt for offers a good level of encryption. For instance, a VPN offers you 256-bit encryption which is used even by military IT infrastructure.
- Number of Anonymous IPs: The service should be able to offer a heavy chunk of IP choices so that you have a plethora of IPs at your disposal.
- Global Server Network: Having a global network of servers spread across the continents means you have plenty of choices to opt for when choosing the IP location.
- Added Features: The service should also offer added security or anonymity features so that you can surf the Internet without any concerns.
Comparison Chart – Tor vs VPN vs Proxy
|Hides your IP Address and Location||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Encrypts Your Traffic & Communications||Yes||No||Yes|
|Unblocks Geo-Restricted Content||Yes||Not all||Not all|
|Works on Games & other Applications||Yes||No||No|
|Slows Down Your Internet||Yes (but not as much as Tor or a proxy)||Yes||Yes|
Frequently Asked Questions
The following are answers to some of the most frequently asked questions about VPN vs. Proxy vs. Tor:
Is It Safe to Use a VPN?
The primary uses of a VPN include online security and streaming, and both the cases imply that using a VPN is completely safe. Moreover, when it comes to online security alone, there’s no other better option than arming your device with a VPN service.
After all, a VPN is known for encryption as well as anonymity. Hence, the decree is that using a VPN is 100% safe.
Is Tor a VPN or Proxy?
It’s neither of the two. Basically, Tor is a software or web browser that keeps your identity and online activity protected against traffic analysis and surveillance. This is made possible by making identification and routing separate processes.
It implements onion routing, which consists of encrypting and bouncing communications randomly across a distributed network of relays operated by thousands of volunteers around the world.
Is Tor Slow?
Many users complain that Tor is slow and offers inconsistent speed, making web browsing a pain in all the wrong places. Well, this can be attributed to the following three reasons:
- Tor enhances your anonymity and privacy by building circuits of three relays, which not only lengthens but also slows down the connection.
- Tor is decentralized, so the quality of the relays differs. Some of them are big and fast, while the others are small and slow.
- Tor is misused by some people, causing network latency and bottlenecks. For example, some people use it for p2p.
Is Tor Better Than a VPN?
Not really. While it also comes down to what your needs are, a VPN is better than Tor and we’re going to explain just why.
Tor is mainly used by people who want to achieve extreme anonymity and hide confidential information such as whistleblowers. Therefore, users might be marked for surveillance if they use Tor frequently, even if they’re not doing anything wrong. Then the slow speed is another issue, so it isn’t exactly the best option for streaming or gaming.
A VPN, on the other hand, not only hides your real IP address but also secures your Internet connection with military-grade encryption – making your online activities truly private. Moreover, it’s legal to use in most countries, and has a less impact on your connection speed (sometimes even improving it depending on the proximity of the VPN server).
What is a Double VPN?
Double VPN is the latest entrant in the VPN industry. Basically, it works by re-routing traffic from the initial VPN server to a second one (in another location), re-encrypting already scrambled data in the process. This makes it difficult for third-parties to get their hands on your information and track where your traffic is originating from. While the increased level of security is great, the downside of this feature is a slower connection speed.
Is VPN Over Tor Safe?
In the VPN over Tor method, a user first connects to the VPN, which establishes the secure, encrypted tunnel. The traffic then passes through the Tor network, and after the still encrypted data comes out of the exit node, it’s transferred to the VPN server, before it finally makes it way to the Internet.
This makes you more anonymous online as the VPN provider can’t see your IP address, and also keeps you safe from malicious nodes because the data is still encrypted when it emerges from the exit node of Tor.
Is Tor Legal?
Yes, Tor is legal. But given that it’s used for illicit activities by certain individuals, it could land you in trouble or bring your online activities into focus.
Is It Safe to Use Proxy?
Queries like these are quite common search engines. However, the answer depends on the type of need you want a proxy service to cater to. For instance, by safe you mean legality of the use, then yes these services are perfectly legal.
However, if by safe you mean online security of your data or activity via the proxy, then no proxy isn’t safe. After all, proxy services are known for speed and it is possible for proxies to deliver you speed only when there is little or no element of encryption involve.
What about the HTTPS proxy? You may wonder. Well, it is true that to a good extent, HTTPS is safe but as long as it is not spoofed. Truth be told, any hacker can spoof the HTTPS server certificate through a Man in the Middle attack.
Do Proxies Slow Down the Internet?
Usually, speed isn’t the issue with some premium proxy services. However, if you opt for a free or public proxy service, you are most likely to face continuous speed issues. The problem often arises due to servers that are overloaded with users. Apart from that low-bandwidth proxy server is another factor behind a slow connection.
Is It Possible to Use VPN and Proxy Together?
Since proxy services usually lack encryption, people often tend to ask whether a VPN and proxy can work together or not. Although you can use both the services together, it is not actually recommended. The mesh up won’t work mainly because of the clash of a proxy server and a VPN server.
Therefore, it is better to go for a VPN service because it offers both anonymity as well as security.
Is Tor Safe?
Yes. Tor is generally safe to use. The tool was created to help users access the Internet anonymously, safely, and freely by anonymizing their traffic and passing it through multiple servers. However, it’s also commonly used to browse the dark web, which can leave you susceptible to attacks from cybercriminals and hackers if you’re not careful.
Does Tor Hide Your IP?
When you connect to the Tor network, your online activities can never be linked back to your actual IP address. This means your ISP won’t be able to tell what you’re doing online, such as the websites you’re vising, apps you’re using, etc.
Can Police Track VPN?
Though the police can see that you’re using a VPN, they don’t know what type of online activities you’re engaging in behind the tool. That said, law enforcement agencies can be subpoena your private information from your VPN provider. To avoid this, make sure that you only choose an independently audited no-log VPN.
Now that you have the complete picture or to be exact a comparison between VPN, Proxy and Tor, you can now easily settle on an anonymity tool for your needs.
However, make sure that whatever tool you opt for must be able to provide you the best encryption as well as privacy.