Static IP Address Vs. DHCP: A Difference Between the Two IP Ideologies

IP addresses are crucial for identifying different devices and establishing communication when managing computer networks. But there are two different ways you can assign this IP address: Static IP or DHCP (Dynamic IP).

Understanding the difference between the two approaches is essential to better optimize network configurations according to your needs. In this blog, we will compare static ip address vs. DHCP in detail so you can be sure when choosing one form of addressing over the other. Let’s get started:

What is a Static IP? 

A static IP address remains fixed and provides a constant network identity to a device. It ensures that a device will permanently get assigned the same address whenever it connects to the internet – this is crucial for easier identification. 

Communication with a static IP is like calling a known phone number. You can easily connect and communicate with a source you are familiar with, and this familiarity is precisely what a static IP provides. It also helps to maintain a stable network connection by allowing port forwarding, remote access, and more!

What is a DHCP? 

DHCP stands for Dynamic Host Configuration Protocol; as the name suggests, it implies a dynamic setup. A DHCP server automatically assigns dynamic IP addresses to devices in this particular setup.

The IP addresses also change a lot as opposed to their static counterpart, and it prevents unknown sources from connecting to your device and reduces security risk. DHCP also simplifies network management by automating the procedure of assignment and renewal of IP addresses. 

Source: Twitter

Static IP address vs. DHCP: Major differences

A static IP address differs from a dynamic IP address due to multiple reasons. Everything from the nature of the address to its use cases offers a stark contrast between the two. Here is a brief comparison between the two:

Static IP Address	Dynamic IP Address
Static IP remains constant every time the device connects to the internet.	Dynamic IP changes every time the device connects to the internet.
Offers a consistent and predictable identity	Does not guarantee the same identity
Can be assigned by the network administrator	Automatically posted by the DHCP server
You can use it to set up servers, remote access, and use better connectivity for gaming consoles.	It can be used for general browsing
Easier to forward ports	More difficult to set up port forwarding
More expensive	More affordable

Source: Broadband Compare

Uses of a Static IP Address

A static IP address is mainly used when a constant and consistent network identity is required. So, even if the network changes or reboots, the device’s static IP addresses remain the same. For example, a particular server has users constantly connecting to it; in this case, the server needs a constant identity.

Therefore, a static IP address is generally assigned to such servers. Like this example, we can use countless scenarios where a static IP address is necessary. Remote access, port forwarding, DNS resolution, etc., can all be catered to using a fixed network identity.

Uses of a Dynamic IP Address

Compared to its static counterpart, a dynamic IP address offers a more general use case by effectively managing and automating IP assignments in a network system. So, whenever a device connects to a network, the DHCP server automatically assigns it a dynamic IP. 

If you have a general network where devices leave and join frequently, like a cafe or a library, a dynamic IP can be assigned to it to help with guest access. Having a dedicated IP address in a wireless network is also quite common, as it effectively optimizes network management and IP allocation. 

Pros and cons of using a Static IP address

A static IP address offers various advantages like easier identification, simplified server management, helps set up multiple services like remote access, and makes port forwarding much easier. 

However, using a static IP address also has a few disadvantages. It can pose a few security concerns if adequate measures are not taken and can be bothersome to configure manually. Here is a breakdown of its pros and cons: 

Static IP: Advantages	Static IP: Disadvantages
Provides a constant network identifier	Manual configuration and management are required
Helps you attain reliable connectivity	Static IP can lead to IP address conflicts if not properly managed
Simplifies access to servers	Much less flexible regarding changes or reconfigurations
Allows to set up port forwarding and remote access	Static IP setup and management may require a little technical knowledge
Simplifies network monitoring	Easier to track and may raise security concerns
Easier DNS server management	Often more expensive than a dynamic IP address

Pros and cons of using a Dynamic IP address

A dynamic IP address assigned by the DHCP server offers an obvious security benefit. Since the IP address changes continuously, keeping track of it or using it to set up unauthorized monitoring becomes much more challenging.

It also provides a significant advantage by automating IP assignments and simplifying network management. But like a static IP, the dynamic IP also has a few disadvantages. Here is a breakdown of the pros and cons of a dynamic IP address:

Dynamic IP: Advantages	Dynamic IP: Disadvantages
Easier network management	More difficult to set up services like remote access or port forwarding
Automates IP allocation	Increased CAPTCHA verification prompts
Less expensive as compared to a static IP address	Issues related to DNS servers and hostings
Manual configuration and management are not required	Inconsistent network and internet speed
More challenging to monitor hence providing better privacy	Many services may specifically require a static IP address
Additional DHCP security features	Additional configurations for DNS resolution
Simplifies network scalability and device integration	Limited control over IP assignments

Static IP address vs. DHCP: Which one to pick?

To better understand the general use cases of both the static and dynamic IP addresses, here is a scenario-based comparison, so that you can better analyze which use type of IP is better for you: 

Home network

The DHCP route is the way to go if you want an IP address for your home network. That is mainly because it automates IP assignments and simplifies network management, so you don’t have to configure it manually.

Complex network

For a complex network, DHCP is generally preferred as it supports scalability. A DHCP server dynamically allocates and reclaims IP addresses depending on the number of devices connected. This feature enables extensive networks to accommodate many devices without manually configuring IP addresses for every device.

Remote access and ports

A static IP address is essential for providing a constant network identifier to set up specific services like remote access or to manage port forwarding. This assigns a fixed address to a system so external devices can easily access it. A DHCP server may require additional reconfigurations for remote access or open ports.

Cost 

Generally, DHCP is more cost-effective as compared to its static counterpart. It automates IP assignments and network management, which helps to reduce administrative overhead. A static IP address is usually more expensive due to manual configuration requirements, potential IP conflicts, and other network administration needs.

Server Hosting

A static IP address is often recommended to host gaming servers, web or mail servers, or some other type of server. A server requires a constant network identity so different devices can quickly identify and connect. It helps to ensure consistent access to the server, which enhances the service experience. 

Security features 

When it comes to security aspects, both IPs offer advantages. A static IP address provides control over IP assignments and implementing security measures. DHCP also makes it harder to track the address due to its dynamic nature and offers various security features like DHCP snooping, IP source guard, DHCP lease time management, etc. 

Mobile devices

DHCP is often preferred for mobile devices because they offer more flexibility. They are easier to use and manage and are much more cost-effective. Your device will automatically get assigned a dynamic IP and there will be no need for manual configuration.

Guest networks

For public spaces like cafes, libraries, hotels, etc. DHCP is much better as it simplifies network management. With many devices connecting and disconnecting to guest networks, a dynamic IP address is much more suitable for this particular use case because it automates IP allocation.

Management 

When it comes to network management, DHCP is much more preferable. In this setup, the IP addresses are assigned automatically; hence, manual configuration is not required. Static IP addresses, on the other hand, need to be configured manually and require much more network administrative work.

Get seamless network connectivity with PureVPN’s Dedicated IP

If you are looking for a way to set up a private gaming server or wish to retrieve some files via remote access, a Dedicated IP address is your best bet! With PureVPN, you can get a Dedicated IP along with many more network benefits! You can enjoy hours of seamless gameplay, stable remote access, and effective port forwarding add-ons to better manage your day-to-day network needs. 

And the best part is that PureVPN also helps you encrypt your network traffic with advanced AES 256-bit encryption so that you are always protected against the wrath of salty competitors and their unauthorized snooping. 

PureVPN offers DNS leak protection and IP masking features to secure your network further and help you access exclusive regional deals, banned content, and other services without restrictions.

• Spoof your IP to access various regional discounts and deals
• Mask your IP to attain complete anonymity
• Host private gaming servers with PureVPN’s Dedicated IP address.
• Connect to 6500+ remote servers in 70+ locations around the globe.
• Open ports with ease using PureVPN’s port forwarding add-on.
• Enjoy advanced network security with AES 256-bit encryption.

To wrap up

All in all, picking one type of IP over the other mainly depends upon your network needs. There is no absolute answer to whether a static IP is better than a dynamic IP or vice versa. Both static and dynamic IP addresses have their share of distinct use cases and pros and cons that can help you decide which type of IP would be suitable for your problem. 

You can also use a reliable VPN, like PureVPN, to get a dedicated IP address to effectively set up private servers and open ports for your favorite games.

Frequently Asked Questions